Search This Blog

Monday, March 22, 2010

Mama's Boy: It Could Happen To You


You might be laughing out loud right now, or you are nodding your head in agreement. It happens to the best of them. While this is a stereotype for a very family oriented male, who in fact loves his mother, there are a few rare instances of when this is all too true. There is a word the Italian community uses for this type of individual, the mammone.

While scouring the Internet or rather Time’s website, I stumbled upon an article that caught me a little bit off guard. The article, addressed a mother in Italy who was accused of being too overbearing. I’ll have to admit, I had a little chuckle when I read this. This is not only because I was doubting that the article was serious but also because I know what it’s like being an Italian-American daughter.

At any rate, the article pressed on and I continued to check things off of my list. The article written by Jeff Israely talks about mothers who do their sons laundry, men who aren’t self-sufficient, and a survey published in Psychology Today that 37% of men in Italy between the ages of 30 to 34 years old still lived at home with their mothers. Before reading either of these articles, I would’ve believed this statistic.

The real twist in the Time article was when I read that this Italian mother and her parents were facing abuse charges. They were being accused of coddling the boy so much his development was stunted. His caregivers, or takers in this case, reportedly prevented him from doing normal activities like running or going to church. The lawyer representing the abused boy said that his motor skills were comparable to those of a 3 year old.

Professional psychologists quoted in the article stated that this type of overprotective behavior can harm children, clearly to the extreme with the Italian boy’s case. In an age of instant media access from the Internet, radio, television, and yes even print—parents and mama’s in particular can take their anxieties too far. I know this circumstance all too well with parents who watch 48 hours and Dateline on a regular basis. I also know this being the youngest daughter of 100% Italian parents, for us it’s worse than the males in my opinion.



The article continues on dissecting the behavior in terms of Italy’s history. Socioeconomics played a huge role in the reason why the Italians (in this case specifically boys) lived with their parents so long. A once extremely poor country with a weak economy, living at home was a wise financial decision. The Catholic church, too, plays an immense role in this. A country where the center of the religion resides and a once devoutly Catholic country had very traditional familial roles for rules until the 1960s. Speaking from personal experience, being both Catholic and Italian, these still are major factors in my life.  Italians are an extremely family oriented cultured who take their faith just as seriously. 
 
While the likelihood of someone becoming a mama’s boy is increased if you are of European decent, it could very well happen to American men. This is not necessarily a bad thing. While one side of the coin says modern women won’t like you because of your dependency on your mother or the archaic views that the mama’s boy holds about wives household duties, the other is very optimistic. Mama’s boys or men, who treat their mothers with respect, are notoriously better communicators with their wives/girlfriends. 
 
Stifling children by preventing them from being independent, girls or boys, is not good developmentally or psychologically. Showing them how to be caring, upstanding citizens, who know how to survive on their own is a very good thing. Perhaps our real concern in today’s society is how much we allow the media to control how we raise our kids. If we just teach them based on what we were taught versus what the media feeds us we’ll be okay. Personally, I’ll  date a mama’s boy any day.

6 comments:

  1. Great blog, Nancy! Loved this article on Italian mama's boys, very well written - I didn't even realize people researched this stuff :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nancy, I have to say, this article really hits the nail on the spot. Our American stereotypes regard maternal affection as a negative social aspect of one's life. Seriously, the slightest mention of maternal love between people of my age (in college), and there go the insults and ridicule. If more people knew the positive effects of maternal love, maybe they could see it in a brighter light, and maybe people that love their mothers (as they should) wouldn't be as ridiculed in society. I think that kind of ridicule helps prevent them from actually caring for their mothers as much as they should be.

    Anyway, nicely written! You'll be a great writer for a prestigious newspaper someday, I know it!

    Love, Boots :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the comments!

    Christina: They definitely do research this stuff. You can find research studies on the Internet done for just about anything that crosses your mind. The day I don't see research done for something, I'll be shocked and maybe do some research of my own. Mama's boys are a topic that American society sees as a almost derogatory (for lack of a better word)statement about a man/boy. I hear guys and their female friends put down Mama's Boys all the time. It's just so funny how one culture accepts it (to a point) while another frowns upon it.

    Boots: Maternal love is definitely something to cherish if you have it. A lot of times family situations are less than ideal for some people and that can either foster jealousy or a mama's boy. Peer pressure in young adults can play a major role in whether or not a son shows affection or not. If you clicked on one of the links ( I think it was the Tesh article/blurb) many famous and well off individuals are mama's boys. It's really nothing to be ashamed of unless carried to extremes.

    Didn't expect to this many comments, keep 'em coming.

    Oh, and I forgot my tagline.

    Grazie,

    Nancy

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nancy,

    So you don't see the term "mama's boy" as a derogatory term? Most people do...I don't, I see it as something admirable and something everyone should be to an extent. Not the extent of your examples, mind you, but detailed nonetheless.

    I wonder what you meant by the "ideal" family situation. That differs by person and background; maybe the term "mama's boy" isn't something that should be frowned upon, since it varies by person.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great article. I'm glad to see reader responses! Hopefully it won't be too over-bearing to remind you to proof everything before posting.

    Dr C

    ReplyDelete
  6. Not over-bearing at all Dr. C!

    ReplyDelete

Leave me a comment:)